Archive for the ‘US/Pakistan Relations’ Category

Pakistan doctor guilty of militancy, not CIA links

May 30, 2012

By RIAZ KHAN | Associated Press

PESHAWAR, Pakistan (AP) — A Pakistan doctor who assisted the CIA in tracking down Osama bin Laden was sentenced to 33 years in prison for conspiring with an Islamist militant commander, a verdict that could make it more difficult for Washington to argue for his release.

The judgment against Shakil Afridi debunked the widely held assumption that he had been convicted for his involvement with the American spy agency.

The decision referred to unspecified evidence that Afridi had “acted” with foreign intelligence agencies, but went on to say any charges related to that couldn’t be considered because the court didn’t have jurisdiction. The Associated Press obtained a copy of the five-page document, first reported by Pakistan’s Dawn newspaper, on Wednesday.

Earlier this week, Afridi’s family and lawyers said he was innocent and would appeal, but said they had not yet seen the court verdict. They refused to comment on his relations with the CIA. The trial was carried out in a court in the country’s tribal regions close to Afghanistan. A political official, in consultation with tribal elders, ruled on the case in secret.

The United States has called for Pakistan to release Afridi, and his punishment has become another flashpoint issue in the fractured relations between the two countries. Pakistan’s army was outraged by the unilateral U.S. raid that killed bin Laden in May 2011 because it was a violation of the country’s sovereignty and added to perceptions it was a sponsor of terror.

Afridi ran a vaccination campaign on behalf of the CIA to collect blood samples from bin Laden’s family at a compound in Abbottabad where U.S. commandos killed the al-Qaida leader. It was unclear whether he succeeded, but U.S. officials have publicly said he helped the effort to track bin Laden.

The fact Afridi was technically convicted for militancy, not helping the CIA, could complicate Washington’s efforts to press for his release. Pakistan could argue that his trial was an internal matter that has nothing to do with the United States.

The verdict said Afridi was guilty of conspiring with a militant group led by commander Mangal Bagh. It said he gave money to the group and treated its leaders at a hospital in Khyber when he was stationed there. According to unnamed witnesses, he did this because of his “deep affiliation with the group.” Others, also unnamed, said the group planned terrorist attacks in Afridi’s office.

The verdict, which was passed down last week, found Afridi guilty of “conspiring against the state” and other charges.

Pakistani officials didn’t attempt to correct widespread reports that the charges referred to his work with the CIA. The verdict triggered anger in the United States and elsewhere, with many questioning how helping kill bin Laden — a sworn enemy of Pakistan — could be seen as working against the state.

The full text of the verdict means Pakistan can now, technically at least, deflect that criticism.

Afridi’s motivation for working with the CIA or whether he was aware who was employing him has never been established. He was once the top medical officer in the Khyber region.

Speaking last week, a friend said he had once been kidnapped by Mangal Bagh’s group and paid a heavy ransom for his release. The friend didn’t give his name because he didn’t want to attract attention to himself.

Pakistan Spy Chief Cancels His Trip To The U.S.

May 29, 2012
ISI DG Lieutenant General Zaheer ul Islam. The Nation


Pakistan Spy Chief Puts Off Washington Visit Amid Rift Over Doctor’s Treason Conviction — Washington Post

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan — Pakistan’s new intelligence chief has postponed his first visit to Washington amid harsh U.S. criticism of the 33-year prison sentence imposed on Shakil Afridi, the Pakistani doctor convicted of treason for aiding the CIA’s hunt for Osama bin Laden.

Lt. Gen. Zaheer ul-Islam, appointed in March to head the powerful Inter-Services Intelligence agency, was set to meet this week with his U.S. counterpart, CIA Director David H. Petraeus, a Pakistani official said.


Update #1: ISI chief postpones US visit — The Nation
Update #2: Resetting Pak-US ties: ISI chief postpones US trip over ‘delay in deal finalisation’ — Express Tribune

My Comment: Lets see …. sentencing the doctor who helped the CIA to find Bin Laden to 33 years in jail …. wanting to charge a fee of $5,000/container to ship goods to Afghanistan …. not eliminating the Taliban safe havens nor imprisoning their leaders who seem to have no problem to walk the streets in public and in full view of Pak security officials.

Yup …. the U.S. is pissed …. and maybe …. finally …. there are some in Pakistan who are getting the message. If not …. I suggest that they should cut even more aid.

Pakistan Reacts To U.S. Criticism Of Doctor’s Treason Conviction For Helping To Find Osama Bin Laden

May 24, 2012

Video grab of Pakistani doctor Afridi talking with people in Pakistan Photo: REUTERS
Pakistan To US: Respect Our Decision To Sentence CIA Informant — Christian Science Monitor

After a Pakistani doctor was sentenced to 33 years in prison on treason charges for helping the CIA find Osama bin Laden, the US protested, saying he was acting against Al Qaeda, not Pakistan.

In response to US ire and a pledge to assist a Pakistani doctor charged with treason for helping the US capture Osama bin Laden, the Pakistani foreign ministry called on the US to “respect” its legal process.

Dr. Shakil Afridi ran a vaccination program to help the CIA collect DNA to verify that the man hiding in Abbotabad was, indeed, Mr. bin Laden. Yesterday Afridi was sentenced to 33 years in prison by a tribal court and issued a $3,500 fine on charges of “conspiring ‘to wage war against Pakistan or depriving it of its sovereignty,’ ‘concealing existence of a plan to wage war against Pakistan’ and ‘condemnation of the creation of the state and advocacy of abolition of its sovereignty’,” Pakistani newspaper Dawn reports.


Update #1: Pakistan rejects U.S. criticism over CIA doctor’s imprisonment — Xinhuanet
Update #2: US threatens to cut Pakistan aid following jailing of Osama bin Laden doctor — The Telegraph

Previous Post: Doctor Who Helped To Find Osama Bin Laden Is Convicted On Treason And Jailed For 33 Years (News Roundup)

My Comment: Not surprisingly …. as this case continues to drag on …. the jailed Pakistani doctor is becoming ’weak and depressed’.